Site Navigation

Home
About
Services
Testimonials
Contact
Info
FAQ

Saxby Insurance Agency, L.L.C.

"Welcome to Saxby Insurance Agency, L.L.C."

About Us

Saxby Insurance Agency, L.L.C. is proud to serve Watertown, WI and communities across Wisconsin as a trusted independent insurance agency. Our mission is simple: to provide personalized coverage at competitive rates while delivering exceptional service every step of the way. As an independent agency, we partner with a wide range of reputable carriers—including CRC Group, Lebanon Seneca Mutual,

Dairyland, Progressive, Forward Mutual, Grinnell Mutual, Hartford (Flood), JM Wilson, Sugar Creek Mutual, Riverside Mutual, and Central Wisconsin Mutual—giving you the flexibility to choose the protection that fits your life and business best.

From auto insurance (including SR-22) and homeowners coverage to farm, renters, and business insurance, we offer solutions for every stage of life. Our specialties also include workers’ compensation, security and fidelity bonds, and notary services—with a public notary available by appointment. Whether you need personal protection or comprehensive business coverage, Saxby Insurance Agency is here to help you navigate your options with confidence and care.

Contact us today for a quote at (920) 261-3334, and connect with us on Facebook for updates and resources.
Thanks, Shelley & Staff

Areas Served

Wisconsin

Our Professional Associations

Better Better Bureau
National Association of Professional Insurance Agents

Our Certifications

Licensed and Insured

What We Offer

Our Specialties include:

At Saxby Insurance Agency, L.L.C., we specialize in comprehensive business insurance solutions designed to protect your company from every angle. From safeguarding physical assets with Commercial Property, Builder’s Risk, and Earthquake Insurance to keeping operations secure through Business Interruption and Business Owners Package policies, we provide coverage that ensures stability and peace of mind. Our expertise extends to Commercial Auto, Trucking, and Cargo Insurance for businesses on the move, as well as Contractor’s Liability and Surety Bonds for construction professionals. We also offer advanced protection with Cyber Liability, Directors & Officers Liability, Employment Practices Liability (EPLI), and Professional Liability (Errors & Omissions) to shield your leadership and reputation. For specialized industries, we deliver tailored solutions including Restaurant, Bar, Tavern, and Liquor Liability Insurance, plus Non-Profit and Farm/Agribusiness coverage. Whether you need

Our Services include:

Auto & Vehicle Insurance: Protect your ride with coverage designed for every type of vehicle. Whether you drive a car, motorcycle, ATV, snowmobile, or RV, we offer policies that safeguard you against accidents, theft, and liability. We also provide SR-22 filings and coverage for underinsured/uninsured motorists to keep you compliant and protected on the road.
Watercraft & Marine Insurance: Enjoy peace of mind on the water with comprehensive protection for boats, personal watercraft, and other marine vehicles. Our policies cover damage, liability, and specialized risks so you can focus on smooth sailing.
Home & Property Insurance: Your home is your haven—let us help you protect it. We offer homeowners, condominium, mobile/manufactured home, and renters insurance to cover your property and belongings. For landlords, our rental property insurance ensures your investment is secure. Flood insurance is also available for added protection against natural disasters.
Farm & Agricultural Insurance: Safeguard your livelihood with tailored farm owners and farm umbrella policies. From your home and equipment to liability coverage, we provide solutions that keep your farm running strong.
Specialty Vehicle & Collector Car Insurance: Own a classic or collector car? We offer specialized coverage to protect your prized possession with policies designed for unique vehicles and their value.
Personal Umbrella Insurance: Extend your protection beyond standard policies with personal umbrella coverage. This extra layer of liability insurance helps shield your assets and future from unexpected claims.
Builders Risk Insurance: For those involved in construction projects, our builders risk insurance covers materials, equipment, and structures during the building process—keeping your investment secure from start to finish.
Event & Wedding Insurance: Celebrate without worry! Our special event and wedding insurance plans protect against unforeseen circumstances like cancellations, liability, and property damage, so your big day stays stress-free.
Property & Liability Coverage: Safeguard your business with comprehensive protection. We offer commercial property insurance, general liability coverage, and commercial umbrella policies to shield your assets from unexpected risks.
Business Owners Package & Interruption Insurance: Our Business Owners Package combines essential coverages into one convenient policy, while business interruption insurance helps keep your operations afloat during unforeseen disruptions.
Commercial Auto & Trucking Insurance: From company cars to full fleets, we provide commercial auto and trucking insurance to keep your business moving forward.
Contractor & Construction Coverage: Builders risk insurance, contractor’s general liability, and surety bonds ensure your projects stay protected from start to finish.
Specialized Industry Coverage: We offer tailored solutions for restaurants, bars, taverns, and liquor liability needs—plus non-profit insurance for organizations that serve the community.
Professional & Executive Protection: Our professional liability (Errors & Omissions), directors and officers liability, and employment practices liability (EPLI) policies help protect your leadership team and business reputation.
Cyber & Product Liability Insurance: Stay ahead of digital threats with cyber liability coverage, and protect your products with specialized product liability insurance.
Farm & Agribusiness Insurance: For agricultural enterprises, we provide comprehensive farm and agribusiness coverage to keep your operations thriving.
Cargo Insurance: Ensure your goods are protected in transit with cargo insurance designed for businesses that depend on reliable delivery.

Our Brands include:

Dairyland Insurance- Auto (including SR-22), Motorcycles, ATV, and UTV
ForemostSTAR
Forward Mutual
Grinnell Mutual Insurance- Commercial and Personal
Hartford Insurance (Flood)
JM Wilson
Lebanon Seneca Mutual Insurance
Progressive Insurance - Auto, Commercial Auto, ATV and UTV, Motorcycles, Boats, Renters
Smart Choice
Sugar Creek Mutual
Riverside Mutual Insurance
Central Wisconsin Mutual Insurance Company
CRC Group

Our Products include:

Auto Insurance
Homeowners Insurance
Business Owners Package Insurance
General Liability Insurance
Commercial Property Insurance
Farm / Agribusiness Insurance
ATV Insurance
Boat & Marine Insurance
Builders Risk Insurance
Collector Car Insurance
Condominium Insurance
Farm Owners Insurance
Farm Umbrella Insurance
Flood Insurance
Mobile (Manufactured) Home Insurance
Motor Home / RV Insurance
Motorcycle Insurance
Non-Owner Insurance
Personal Umbrella Insurance
Personal Watercraft Insurance
Rental Property Insurance
Renters Insurance
Snowmobile Insurance
Special Event Insurance
SR-22
Underinsured/Uninsured Motorists Coverage
Wedding Insurance
Business Insurance Types:
Builder’s Risk Insurance
Business Interruption Insurance
Cargo Insurance
Commercial Auto Insurance
Commercial Earthquake Insurance
Commercial Trucking Insurance
Commercial Umbrella Insurance
Contractor’s General Liability Insurance
Cyber Liability Insurance
Directors and Officers Liability Insurance
Employment Practices Liability Insurance (EPLI)
Liquor Liability Insurance
Non-Profit Insurance
Product Liability Insurance
Professional Liability (Errors & Omissions) Insurance
Restaurant & Bar Insurance
Tavern Insurance
Surety Bonds

Testimonials

On 12/4/2024 Debbie S had this to say:
Shelley is awesome to work with. Her pleasant disposition and willingness to help is terrific! Testimonial written by Debbie S on this site.

On 11/10/2024 John Freson had this to say:
The insurance team is fantastic at answering my inquires. They are fair, and affordable, Thanks. Testimonial written by John Freson on this site.

On 9/12/2024 Hallow Arts had this to say:
Shelley was very helpful for me. I recommend through their agency.

On 5/16/2023 Gary Mills had this to say:
I was with another company. Just raised my rates. Patronizing me over the cost of a sheet of plywood. really. I moved from Illinois, to Watertown WI. A little frustrated, I decided to go LOCAL. I investigated insurance companies in Watertown. Saxby Ins online had the most to offer so I selected Saxby's. I had my initial appointment, I felt very at home and safe, I wasn't going to be taken. Immediately Shelley reviewed my current polices, auto and home, found some interesting things, Shelley did her magic, and saved me near 900 dollars PLUS giving me BETTER coverage. I'm glad to be a Saxby Insurance member. Thank you. Testimonial written by Gary Mills on this site.

On 12/22/2022 Milt Laforge had this to say:
Shelly is very friendly and very very helpful. saved me 160.00 a month

Contact Us

Saxby Insurance Agency, L.L.C.
210 W Main St Watertown, WI 53094
Phone: (920) 261-3334
Fax: (920) 261-3530
Email: saxbyinsurance@gmail.com

Across the street from the Library. Next to Mullen's Dairy

Where To Find Us

Payment Types Accepted

Visa, MasterCard, Personal Checks, Debit Cards

Our Hours

Monday: 9:00 AM - 4:30 PM
Tuesday: 9:00 AM - 4:30 PM
Wednesday: 9:00 AM - 5:00 PM
Thursday: 9:00 AM - 5:00 PM
Friday: 9:00 AM - 12:00 PM

Info

BBB

FAQ

Do you serve both personal and business clients?

Yes — we offer insurance solutions for both individuals and businesses.

How do I request a quote?

Call us at (920) 261-3334 or visit our office to discuss your coverage needs and receive a personalized quote.

What types of insurance do you offer?

We provide a full range of coverage options including:

Auto Insurance
Homeowners Insurance
Farm Insurance
Renters Insurance
Business Insurance
Workers’ Compensation
Bonds